CHINA, PACIFIC ISLANDS & THE WEST’S DOUBLE STANDARDS



For Pacific Islands countries (PIC), the current geostrategic, geoeconomic and geopolitical discussions, especially around the Indo-Pacific strategy, is framed in three ways. First, the vulnerability narrative, which portrays PICs as vulnerable and therefore susceptible to outside influence, especially from China. Second, the treatment of PICs as pawns in the power play-off between the larger countries. Third, the portrayal of PICs as having no agency in the relations that they forge. All of these frames are problematic.

But here, let me deal with the vulnerability frame.Underlying this narrative are the interests of the metropolitan countries, rather than those of Pacific Islands countries. Western countries are worried that the dominance they enjoyed in the region since WWII is now being threatened by China’s growing influence. The Quadrilateral partners’ (Quads) – U.S., Australia, Japan and India – rhetorical and policy responses to China’s growing influence in the region are driven by their own vulnerabilities, not those of Pacific Island countries. It is the western countries that are vulnerable. Not the PICs.

In this narrative, Pacific Island countries are treated as pawns in the power play-off by the powerful countries. Here, Pacific Island countries are treated as not important, in and of themselves, but only vis-à-visthe interests and security of western countries and the Quads. Hence, when Oceania is mentioned in the Indo-Pacific discussions, it is largely about how it could be used to serve the interests of western countries and their allies. Oceania is treated as a geostrategic, geopolitical and geoeconomic space where powerful countries exert their influence. In discussions, PICs are treated as pawns in their power play-offs. This is reminiscent of the Cold War era when the Oceania region was often regarded as an Anglo-Franco-American lake and where western countries deployed a policy of “strategic denial.”

Chinese concessional loans have been peddled as the biggest threat. But those who peddle this narrative often forget that the Bretton Wood Institutions – the World Bank & IMF – have, since the 1960s, given loans to Third World countries and forced them to build infrastructure that they could not afford. It created “debt traps” for many Third World countries. Those institutions then introduced structural adjustment programs, which were largely means through which they pushed neo-liberal policies, especially trade liberalization.

I am not saying that it is good to be in debt to China. 

Rather, western countries’ double standards and selective amnesia about history never ceases to amaze me. It is arrogance that borders on racism. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A LEAP INTO THE UNKNOWN: Togamae’s Journey from Isabel to Portland

Image
By   Dr. Tarcisius Kabutaulaka Dr. Ishmael Togamae in Hawai'i From a humble beginning in a village in the mountains of Santa Isabel, Dr. Ishmael Togamae has walked paths  no other Solomon Islander had previously trekked. And it has taken him a long way. He and his family now live in Portland, Oregon, in the west coast of the U.S. where he works as a medical doctor. But the journey to Portland has been long and arduous.              Ishmael remembers, as a child having to walk for miles five-days-a-week, from Gurena, his childhood village in the highlands of Maringe to attend school at Nareabu on the coast. “I recall walking down slippery slopes of rugged bush tracks. I was the youngest kid from Gurena going to school at that time, and so I was often left behind.   “I cried many times because I was scared; and worse because the track traversed through a cattle farm. I was scared of the cattle,” he says meditatively, as though captured in his childhood memories.
Read more

FIJIAN CAREGIVES FOR PhD: ROKOLEKUTU'S JOURNEY

Image
Dr. Ponipate Rokolekutu       By Dr. Tarcisius Kabutaulaka It was a beautiful day on 16 th December 2017. The Stan Sheriff Center at the University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa was packed with excited graduates, relatives, friends, faculty and dignitaries. It was the University’s fall commencement ceremony. When his name was called, Ponipate Rokolekutu walked up to the podium, was hooded and then presented with a piece of paper acknowledging his achievements. It was a gesture welcoming this Fijian lad from Vunimono in Tailevu into the global community of academics. Rokolekutu received a PhD in political science, making him the first iTaukei to have been awarded a PhD in that department at the University of Hawai ʻ i. He looks sober and dignified in his graduation gown. But behind his sober demeanor and the infectious smile that beams through his spectacles are stories of struggles. Growing up, his parents struggled to look after him and his five siblings. Being the e
Read more

SOLOMON ISLANDERS GRADUATE FROM UNIVERSITY OF HAWAIʻI

Image
  Two Solomon Islanders were among the 4,800 students who graduated from the University of Hawaiʻi  in a number of commencement ceremonies held last Saturday and Sunday.  Both  Solomon Islanders graduated with Masters degrees. They are Cathy Hite who graduated with a Masters in Law and Enly Saeni Labuinao who graduated with a Masters in Sociology. CATHY HITE  graduated  from UH's Richardson School of Law.  Her Masters degree  specializes in Business Commercial Law and in International and Comparative Law. Cathy comes from Weʻa Village in South Malaita.  She did her primary school in Waneagu, Nafinua and Maka schools on Malaita. She then went on to King George VI school where she did forms 1 to 3 before going on to St. Josephs Tenaru for forms 4 to 6, and then back to KGVI for form 7.  She then went to the University of the South Pacific ’ s E malus Campus in Port Vila, Vanuatu, where she completed a Bachelor of Law degree in 2012. In 2013, Cathy  comp
Read more